We'll be back, don't worry!

We're just moving houses (and inventory).

Be patient with us we'll be back in time for Fall 2022!


Since 2012 Rotten Rentals has been bringing nostalgia back to collectors everywhere with our VHS mystery box! We missed browsing the VHS shelves full of amazing covers that ultimately decided which film we took home that night.

So how does it work? We start with an empty VHS clamshell, of course. Next, we print a reproduction horror cover*. Then we curate each box to have a random assortment of vintage trading cards, buttons, stickers, Pogs, mini zombie figures, and more!

*We do not charge for the reproduction cover. This includes the ones we make entirely from scratch. Each cover is modified in some way and is only an homage to the original film. The money you pay is to reimburse the products that we purchased and the labor of assembly.


Want free shipping? You got it. If you buy $40 or more of anything on our site, you will be greeted with an option for free shipping! If you order under $40, no problem, shipping is now a set price of $8 no matter what. This is only possible due to the unwavering support of our friends and fans! Pat yourself on the back.

They're heerrreeee!

They've just come down in price from $20 to $17, so go ahead get you a  shirt. They range in size from small to 3XL! If you are needing a larger size, just email us. We got you covered (pun intended).


We’ve teamed up with great artists to bring you limited edition VHS Packs! Limited to 25 or 50 print runs, once these packs fly off the shelves they will be gone forever. Pick one up today and support indie artists! Featuring the artwork of Patrick Carson Sparrow, Zack Wallenfang, Trevor Henderson, Brandon Duncan and more!

Be sure to check out our Fright Rags Collection Hatchet Limited Edition VHS pack.

Got a young one that you're trying to get into horror and sci-fi? Or a kid that just won't leave you alone and needs something to do?! Check out our Spoiled Rotten packs for kids. The covers and the contents are age-appropriate and only $5 each! We have custom and classic covers too!